OP updated with the new profiles. Sorry that I can't accept the VS. screen though. Due to the number of potential combinations of attorney and prosecutor, it's just not feasible to keep all of them here. It's a great VS. screen though, especially if you're going for a more comedic case.
OP updated. By the way, I wish I had the foresight to take care of this earlier, but now, several of the files in the OP have been affected by the Dropboxalypse. If anyone has any copies of the missing files that they can upload, that'd be great.
Figured I may as well hand over the custom evidence from my past trials. It's mostly basic recolours, but hey, it might save somebody 10 minutes in MS paint. You don't need to bother crediting if you want to use any of this.